Mineral Rights vs. Real Estate: The Passive Income Play No One Talks About

Imagine collecting checks every month—without tenants calling, toilets overflowing, or property managers eating into your margins.

September 26, 20254 min read

Sounds like real estate nirvana, right? Except this isn’t about rentals. It’s about mineral rights—an asset class most investors never consider, yet one that often delivers stronger cash flow with fewer moving parts.

If you’re a real estate investor who’s tired of constant management but still hungry for yield and upside, this deserves your attention.

What is mineral rights, really?

Mineral rights give you ownership of what’s beneath the surface—oil, gas, or other resources.

You don’t drill. You don’t operate. An energy company does the work, and you get a royalty check if production happens.

Mineral rights generally fall into three buckets:

  • Non-producing: No lease, no income.

  • Leased but not producing: Some near-term potential, maybe lease bonuses.

  • Producing: The crown jewel—active wells generating monthly royalty checks.


Real Estate Snapshot: Where Yields Sit Today

Take Texas as an example:

  • Class A multifamily in Houston/Dallas → ~5% cap rates.

  • Value-add suburban multifamily → ~6.5–7%.

Not bad, but remember the realities: vacancies, repairs, property taxes, insurance, and the ongoing need for management.

Mineral Rights Snapshot: What’s Happening in Texas

  • Non-producing: Often less than $250/acre.

  • Leased but idle: 2–3× the lease bonus (e.g., $1,000/acre bonus → $2,000–$3,000 sale price).

  • Producing in prime basins: $18,000–$25,000 per royalty acre isn’t unusual in the Permian.

Royalty rates? Generally 12.5%–25%, with 18–20% being common.


Side-by-Side: Real Estate vs. Minerals

Metric

Real Estate

Mineral Rights (Producing)

Initial Investment

$300k duplex, plus renovation, plus tenant improvements

$100k producing interest in Permian

Ongoing Costs

Taxes, insurance, repairs, turnover

Minimal admin/tax; operator handles drilling

Annual Net Yield

$20k net ($300k investment) → 6.7%

$14.4k royalties ($100k investment) → 14.4%

Volatility

Rent cycles, vacancy

Commodity prices, production decline


Risk Isn’t Gone—It’s Just Different

Mineral rights aren’t magic. The risks shift:

  • Commodity swings: Oil and gas prices rise and fall.

  • Decline curves: Wells start strong, then taper off.

  • Liquidity: Fewer buyers, more niche market.

  • Regulatory changes: Rules and taxes can shift.

But compare that to tenants trashing a unit or a roof caving in—and many investors prefer the trade-off.


Why Mineral Rights Can Shine

  • True passivity: No late-night calls.

  • High yield: Double-digit returns in producing basins are realistic.

  • Inflation hedge: Commodity prices often track inflation more directly than rent.

  • Upside optionality: New wells, lease bonuses, or better technology can improve returns.


Real-World Example

  • Real Estate: $300,000 duplex in Dallas suburbs → $20,000/year net after headaches → 6.7% yield.

  • Minerals: $100,000 producing interest → $1,200/month royalties = $14,400/year → 14.4% yield.

Even factoring in production decline, the margin is real—and the lifestyle is lighter.

How to Think Moving Forward

If you’re already invested in real estate:

  • Keep your base there for stability.

  • Add 5–15% of new capital to producing mineral rights in strong basins.

  • Prioritize deals with clear title, high royalty percentages, and verifiable production history.

  • Benchmark against your real estate returns: if minerals are netting 10–15%, they’ve earned a seat at the table.

The smartest portfolios often mix both. Real estate builds equity and stability; mineral rights bring cash flow and upside without the management grind.

Growth Risk

Bottom Line

Mineral rights are the hidden cousin of real estate investing—cash flow without the clutter.

For investors seeking diversification, yield, and freedom from constant management, they may be the passive income play no one talks about… but more should.

💡 The Passive Income Play No One Talks About

Every investor knows the classic pitch:
👉 Buy real estate.
👉 Collect rent.
👉 Build wealth.

But here’s the truth no one says out loud: tenants, toilets, and turnover are real. And they chip away at both returns and sanity.

That’s why I’ve been digging into an overlooked asset class most investors never consider: mineral rights.

Here’s why they’re worth your attention:

  • Operators drill. You collect checks.

  • No property management, no capital repairs.

  • In the right basins, yields can hit double digits—often outperforming rentals.

  • Inflation hedge: commodity prices tend to move with inflation faster than rent.

👉 Real-world example:

  • A Dallas duplex nets ~6.7% after expenses.

  • Producing mineral rights in the Permian? ~14.4% yield with no tenant drama.

Are minerals risk-free? No.
The risks shift—commodity prices, production decline, niche liquidity. But compared to leaky roofs and late rent, some investors find that trade-off worth it.

I just published a full breakdown:
“Mineral Rights vs. Real Estate: The Passive Income Play No One Talks About.”

In it, I cover:
✔️ Yield comparisons
✔️ Volatility & exit options
✔️ Tax treatment differences
✔️ When minerals shine (and when they don’t)

Got it — here’s a polished edit of your text that shifts it toward driving traffic to a webinar, while keeping the curiosity hook intact and making the CTA clear:

If you’re already in real estate—or looking for smarter ways to diversify—this webinar is one you don’t want to miss.

👉CLICK HERE TO WATCH THIS WEBINAR NOW

⚠️ Don’t just read about passive income—see exactly how it works. Seats for the upcoming webinar are limited and filling fast.

CLICK HERE TO WATCH


Tommy Brachey isn’t just a name in real estate—he specializes in mineral rights. As Owner of Key Real Estate Consulting and Advisor Vice President with eXp Commercial, Tommy teaches brokers, investors, and entrepreneurs how to transform leftover 1031 exchange funds into cash-flowing, tax-advantaged assets.

Traveling from Dallas to Honolulu, Tommy leads 1031 exchange seminars and investor meetups, simplifying complex deals and showing how mineral rights provide passive income, tax deferral, and effective property portfolio growth.

The question is not if mineral rights are worth looking at. The real question is how much longer can you afford to overlook them.

Tommy Brachey

Tommy Brachey isn’t just a name in real estate—he specializes in mineral rights. As Owner of Key Real Estate Consulting and Advisor Vice President with eXp Commercial, Tommy teaches brokers, investors, and entrepreneurs how to transform leftover 1031 exchange funds into cash-flowing, tax-advantaged assets. Traveling from Dallas to Honolulu, Tommy leads 1031 exchange seminars and investor meetups, simplifying complex deals and showing how mineral rights provide passive income, tax deferral, and effective property portfolio growth. The question is not if mineral rights are worth looking at. The real question is how much longer can you afford to overlook them.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog